2021 NAIA Women’s All-West Region
| Pos | Name | Class | School | Hometown |
| K | Mackenzie Osther | Sr. | Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University (Ariz.) | San Diego, Calif. |
| D | Aniyah Gibbs | So. | John Brown University | Muskogee, Okla. |
| D | Aubrey Mendez | Jr. | John Brown University | Chino, Calif. |
| D | Makena Wood | Sr. | University of Science & Arts (Okla.) | Wichita Falls, Texas |
| M | Haley Harris | Fr. | Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University (Ariz.) | Tucson, Ariz. |
| M | Vanessa Reynoso | Sr. | John Brown University | Springdale, Ark. |
| M | Ryan Winingham | So. | John Brown University | Highlands Ranch, Colo. |
| F | Mackenzie Holub | Jr. | University of Science & Arts (Okla.) | Edmond, Okla. |
| F | Emma Rice | Jr. | University of Science & Arts (Okla.) | Norman, Okla. |
| F | Lily Schlake | Sr. | College of Idaho | Meridian, Idaho |
| F | Sierra Vicente | Jr. | Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University (Ariz.) | Las Vegas, Nev. |
2021 NAIA Women’s All-North Region
| Pos | Name | Class | School | Hometown |
| K | Emily Ponstein | Sr. | Spring Arbor University | Hudsonville, Mich. |
| D | Sydney Genatempo | Sr. | Marian University | Westfield, Ind. |
| D | Merin McDermott | Sr. | Aquinas College | Grandville, Mich. |
| D | Becca Mindling | Sr. | Spring Arbor University | Grand Rapids, Mich. |
| M | Mallory Krueger | So. | Indiana Wesleyan | Overland Park, Kan. |
| M | Mackenzie Selvius | Sr. | Spring Arbor University | Grand Rapids, Mich. |
| M | Allie Schlom | Jr. | Marian University | Missouri City, Texas |
| F | Hannah Crum | Sr. | Aquinas College | Waterford, Mich. |
| F | Madison Marshall | Sr. | Spring Arbor University | Belleville, Mich. |
| F | Erin Oleksak | Jr. | Marian University | Palatine, Ill. |
| F | Briana Uhl | Sr. | Trinity Christian College | Upland, Calif. |
2021 NAIA Women’s All-Central Region
| Pos | Name | Class | School | Hometown |
| K | Nerea Mora | Sr. | Oklahoma Wesleyan University | Valencia, Spain |
| D | Ruth Khasoha | Sr. | Oklahoma Wesleyan University | Nairobi, Kenya |
| D | Natalia Ruiz | Jr. | Missouri Valley College | Bogota, Colombia |
| D | Emma Strecker | So | Benedictine College | Kansas City, Mo. |
| M | Morgan Dierks | Jr. | Missouri Valley College | Kansas City, Kan. |
| M | Jody Ellis | Sr | Culver-Stockton College | Troy, Ill. |
| M | Kamryn Fiscus | Jr. | University of Jamestown | Yakima, Wash. |
| F | Cassandra Diaz | Jr. | University of Jamestown | Montebello, Calif. |
| F | Laura Maria | Sr. | Oklahoma Wesleyan University | Tubarao, Brazil |
| F | Marjolen Nekesa | Sr. | Oklahoma Wesleyan University | Nairobi, Kenya |
| F | Melissa Siegel | Jr. | Baker University | Endingen, Germany |
2021 NAIA Women’s All-East Region
| Pos | Name | Class | School | Hometown |
| K | Grace McClellan | Fr. | Keiser University | Southside, Ala. |
| D | Maja Henriksson | So. | Keiser University | Gothenburg, Sweden |
| D | Veronica Herrera | Sr. | William Carey University | Caracas, Venezuela |
| D | Camila Pescatore | Jr. | William Carey University | Valencia, Venezuela |
| M | Addie Adame | Jr. | Georgia Gwinnett College | Lilburn, Ga. |
| M | Kyoka Koshijima | Jr. | Keiser University | Kanzawa City, Japan |
| M | Ana Paula Santos | Sr. | William Carey University | Sao Paulo, Brazil |
| F | Adisa Amang | Sr. | University of Tennessee Southern | Kumba, Cameroon |
| F | Keito Ido | Fr. | University of Tennessee Southern | Tokyo, Japan |
| F | Ramona Kannady | Fr. | Keiser University | Zurich, Switzerland |
| F | Yuki Watari | Jr. | University of Tennessee Southern | Sao Paulo, Brazil |