2021 United Soccer Coaches NAIA Women’s Scholar All-America Team
| Pos | Name | Class | School | Major | GPA | Hometown |
| K | Grace McClellan | Jr. | Keiser University | Business | 4.00 | Southside, Ala. |
| D | Maja Henriksson | Jr. | Keiser University | Business | 3.85 | Gothenburg, Sweden |
| D | Veronica Herrera | Sr. | William Carey University | General Studies | 3.49 | Caracas, Venezuela |
| D | Camila Pescatore | Jr. | William Carey University | Business Administration | 3.63 | Valencia, Venezuela |
| M | Kyoka Koshijima* | Sr. | Keiser University | Business | 3.68 | Kanazawa City, Japan |
| M | Ana Paula Santos | Sr. | William Carey University | Interscholastic Athletic Administration | 3.81 | Sao Paulo, Brazil |
* – previous selection
National Scholar Player of the Year bolded.