2018 United Soccer Coaches NCAA Division III Men's Scholar All-America Team
| First Team | ||||||
| Pos | Name | Class | School | Major | GPA | Hometown |
| K | Dylan McLaurin* | Sr. | University of Lynchburg | International Relations | 3.62 | Stafford, Va. |
| D | Daniel Hedstrom | Jr. | Augsburg University | Marketing | 3.63 | Hermantown, Minn. |
| D | Cole Rosenberger | Sr. | Johns Hopkins University | Environmental Engineering | 3.94 | Indiana, Pa. |
| D | Mark Roth* | Sr. | Carleton College | Computer Science | 3.61 | Evanston, Ill. |
| D | Trent Vegter | Sr. | Calvin College | Engineering | 3.46 | Hudsonville, Mich. |
| M | Justin Carey* | Sr. | University of Mary Washington | Business | 3.36 | Leesburg, Va. |
| M | Topher Marshall* | Sr. | Oglethorpe University | Communication Studies | 3.30 | Lawrenceville, Ga. |
| M | Aidan O'Driscoll* | Sr. | Luther College | English | 3.56 | Minneapolis, Minn. |
| M | Peder Olsen | Jr. | North Park University | Business | 3.91 | Larvik, Norway |
| F | Joseph Braun | Jr. | Tufts University | International Relations | 3.39 | Yardley, Pa. |
| F | Max Lopez | Sr. | University of Chicago | Environmental & Global Studies | 3.55 | Tulsa, Okla. |
| F | Samuel Ruiz Plaza | Sr. | Messiah College | Biology | 3.66 | Woodbury, Minn. |
| Second Team | ||||||
| Position | Name | Class | School | Major | GPA | Hometown |
| D | Tommy Bitter | Sr. | University of Wisconsin-Platteville | Civil Engineering | 3.34 | Dubuque, Iowa |
| D | Sebastian Gordon-Somers-Archer | Sr. | SUNY New Paltz | Marketing | 3.35 | Forest Hills, N.Y. |
| D | Michael Tanchevski | Jr. | Wabash College | Biology | 3.54 | Crown Point, Ind. |
| D | Sterling Weatherbie | Sr. | Tufts University | Economics | 3.56 | Cape Elizabeth, Maine |
| M | Nicco Capotosto | Sr. | University of Chicago | Psychology & Public Policy | 3.46 | Holland, Mich. |
| M | Bryce Ikeda* | Sr. | University of Rochester | Electrical & Computer Engineering | 3.68 | Tacoma, Wash. |
| M | Jake Keller | Jr. | SUNY Cortland | Sport Management | 3.71 | Wappingers Falls, N.Y. |
| M | Benjamin Manoogian | Sr | Connecticut College | Economics | 3.51 | Peabody, Mass. |
| M | Gavin Tasker | Jr. | Tufts University | Quantitative Economics | 3.69 | Lincoln, Mass. |
| M | Jonathan Burton | Sr. | Grove City College | Biology | 3.71 | Columbus, Ohio |
| F | Dylan Ritch | Sr. | Washington & Lee University | Accounting & Business Administration | 3.44 | Mint Hill, N.C. |
| F | Danny Ruple | Jr. | Baldwin Wallace University | Accounting & Finance | 3.89 | Berea, Ohio |
| Third Team | ||||||
| Position | Name | Class | School | Major | GPA | Hometown |
| K | Chris Ralph | Sr. | Penn State University-Behrend | Project &` Supply Chain Management | 3.46 | Murrysville, Pa. |
| D | Conner Couchot | Sr. | Endicott College | Finance | 3.54 | Mason, Ohio |
| D | Riley Doherty | Sr. | Worcester Polytechnic Institute | Industrial Engineering & Economics | 3.83 | Shrewsbury, Mass. |
| D | Jacob Lysik* | Sr. | Aurora University | Finance | 3.92 | New Lenox, Ill. |
| D | Matty McColl | Sr. | Bowdoin College | Government & Legal Studies/Asian Studies | 3.71 | Victoria, B.C. |
| D | Justin Schmidt | Jr. | Webster University | Film Production | 3.51 | St. Louis, Mo. |
| M | Justin Brautigam | Sr. | Messiah College | Athletic Training | 3.57 | Doylestown, Pa. |
| M | Rafael Broseghini | Sr. | Luther College | Computer Science | 3.49 | Rio de Janiero, Brazil |
| M | Steven Dang | Sr. | University of Mary Hardin-Baylor | Nursing | 3.34 | Dallas, Texas |
| M | Garrett Lee | Sr. | Edgewood College | Business Management | 3.83 | Menomonee Falls, Wis. |
| F | Alex Besl | Sr. | Case Western Reserve University | Economics & Finance | 3.81 | Cincinnati, Ohio |
| F | Miguel Pina | Sr. | Central College | Exercise Science/Spanish | 3.41 | Chicago, Ill. |
| F | Ryan Sproule* | Sr. | Washington University (Mo.) | Computer Science | 3.55 | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
* - Indicates previous selection